cup cup sip sip yep yep YURR

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

It's been brought to my attention that we haven't had a thread about Electrik Red, despite them being seriously relevant to our interests for the last, err, year. So let's do that.

Here is a piece of largely irrelevant writing on the topic that I've spewed out in the last ten seconds, excuse my grammar:

So we're fairly used, by now, to the slew of whorepop that's appeared in the US girlgroup arena following the surprising success of My Secret Favourite Band, The Pussycat Dolls. It's a sort of delicate combination between sassiness and a brutal level of crudeness that crosses the 'sexy' line into almost emo morbidity levels in terms of 'excessive honesty.' Or TMI, whatever. I absolutely love all the whorepoppers, from the emotionally resonant 'Dolls to the straight-up skanks that are Girlicious to Danity Kane's stripper-in-an-empty-club routine; I partly like them because I frankly can't be getting along with good girls and I see them as an extension of, say, Courtney Love et al who I worshipped as an early teenager and also because the music is layered harmony awesomeness and the overall result is me finding a new favourite genre.

Still, they're not quite me. In the same way that Courtney Love is not quite me. I see what they're doing but I generally can just about keep my clothes from falling off and have a vague concept of how to use Twitter. Where I'm just not particularly respectable, these young ladies are no-nonsense, well-groomed slvts and well, I'm maybe just a little too lazy for that. Same way as I probably can't be bothered to marry Kurt Cobain, historical continuity problems aside. The Danities and the Courtneys and the Dolls are fvcked up in ways that I can relate to but through a sort of 'there is a general theory here which is relevant to the both of us' lens, rather than as a directly applicable thing.

Then there's Electrik Red; easily confusable for whorepop, insofar as they have the same brazen approach to lyrics and a certain propensity for not bothering to hide the fvcked up aspects of How They Roll but ...different. Where the PCDs now look almost Disney somehow (partly due to various bar-raising activities cf. Tila Tequila et al) and have acquired an air of good, clean fun, whilst the Danities implode and who the fuck knew what Girlicious were doing in the first place, Electrik Red are sort of ...real. They get drunk, they fvck innappropriate people, they get so emo they can't get out of bed, they have one of those weeks where you feel exactly in control of things for five minutes, they fvck themselves in the head with stupid men, etc.

I'm willing to concede that I'm never going to be that well-groomed but somehow Electrik Red feel like they're much more me. I was going to say 'girls like me' but I think I mean 'people,' occasional gender politics in their songs aside. The lyrical TMI gets the same heart-swelling-and-bursting formula right as, say, Pete Wentz or Conor Oberst does; a little too honest, a little too raw, a little too vicious and faintly embarassing for that. Sort of lyrical blogging, from the drunken Twitter updates of 'Drink In My Cup' to the epic thoughtmaze of 'So Good,' which is basically the sound of those thoughts that stop you dead in front of the kettle/telly/front door/etc. and temporarily take all your braneRAM for their own crush-y purposes. And then there's 'We Fvck You,' which is a really ballsy discussion with yr friends, instantly deleted by 'So Good' existing; whilst 'thought I wouldn't really give a fvck' =/= being the fvcker rather than the fvckee, there's a ho-rap hardness to WFY that all turns out to be bravado when the emo kicks in, which isn't because they're grills or whatever, it's because most people are actually kind of emo and the gender-political posturing turns out to just be rubbish because you can relate to boys after all etc. WHICH IS AWESOME.

I know I'm probably DOIN IT RONG by revelling in the emo aspects of slvtpop but 'Bed Rest' is seriously amazing;

And they swear all over the place, whilst somehow managing to actually look quite big and clever. As part of the Eminem generation, I obviously think swearing is a brilliant idea: V GOOD, TICK.

Anyway, I should probably do some work and this is absolute nonsense, so DISCUSSION: GO. Feel free to post details of yr own relation to (or dislocation from) the 'Red.

Comments

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

Nooooo FOB lyrics are GREBT because they are all about Pete and Patrick, really. Not in an omgfanfiction way, in the sense that it's their mentalist friendship that's the real thing; Patrick telling Pete to pull it together and Pete telling Patrick to fvck off and etc. Really the Wentz comparison is more about the ...overrealism of some things, like in 'So Good,' where she's like 'thought I wouldn't really give a fvck, now a b1tch all in love' is sort of... too close to the bone, somehow, like too much of a vulnerable admission because of the persona of Electrik Red? [ed: and the relevance to this w/r/t FOB is stuff like 'why don't you show me the little bit of spine you've been saving for his mattress/I only want sympathy in the form of you crawling into bed with me' where it's like '...too much, Pete, even for you'] Idk idk idk blee that Lady Gaga thing has fried what remained of my brain.

I have noticed that the people more wild about the lyrics seem generally more madly enthusiastic about ER (and by this I mean 'me and Cis and Lex were having a fanpersonism squee regarding their brilliance the other day in the pub' although as me and katstevens were discussing, not something you want to get caught singing in the cantine queue by accident.

Tbh I've pretty much accepted that discussion posts are met with general apathy. We have trained people to tick boxes too well. Also, harder to read at werk.

[freakytigger.livejournal.com]

Oh I love the record for its sound, just couldn't quote any of it.

[freakytigger.livejournal.com]

And those Wentz lyrics don't seem too much or anything, they're like Elvis Costello but done with web-era performative flair. It's not that I think Wentz is fakin' the emo or anything, just that "relating to" his lyrics isn't a deal for me. But on the other hand it kind of IS, because FOB totally glamorises those kind of situations, like some pop glamorises violence, so listening gives you a kind of wounded swagger.

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

I think tbh I just thought of that line because it seemed like what might happen if Pete circa Cork Tree shagged Electrik Red circa 'Bed Rest.' (ie: FACEPALM ALL ROUND)

My brain is not really working today, though.

[cis.livejournal.com]

Nooooo FOB lyrics are GREBT because they are all about Pete and Patrick, really. Not in an omgfanfiction way, in the sense that it's their mentalist friendship that's the real thing; Patrick telling Pete to pull it together and Pete telling Patrick to fvck off and etc.

this is exactly what someone could say about The Libertines!

v few FOB lyrics are about Pete and Patrick you fanfictual mentalist, they are majority Conor Oberst-style 'pete and girls he has slept with or will sleep with' or 'pete and pete'.

[cis.livejournal.com]

genuinely i am having a lot of difficulty thinking of any lyrics that can be assumed to be about Patrick w/out tinhattery!

on the other hand I did just remember that that 'bang the doldrums' is apparently canonically about Mikey out of MCR.

(obviously 'girls he has slept with or will sleep with' includes 'the ~fans~' not because he will sleep with them but because in the fangirl's heart there must always a suggestion of 'you too could be like peyton in one tree hill' even if the thought is faintly offputting)

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

Weeeell yes. Although 'Folie A Deux' is JUST Pete/Patrick, really. And retrospectively, quite a lot of the rest probably is. You could say it about a lot of bands, really. It's just I LIKE Pete and Patrick.

Cus Patrick sings them, he always ends up tied up in it, anyway. The fact of Pat singing them is always going to mean Pete's putting the criticisms of himself into Patrick's mouth and ...oh, I should just write the thing I keep trying to remember to write about this but it always comes out a bit fannish and I don't actually really know that much about FOB beyond the music.

I do not read FOB fanfic! At work, anyway...

[cis.livejournal.com]

if you have fanfic in your heart you do not need to read it! AS EVIDENCED HERE.

Folie a Deux is pretty much Pete/fans? occasionally Pete/fame? Briefly Youth Of America/Obama?

It's funny, "[lyricist] puts self-criticism into mouth of [singer]" is true of a bunch of bands, it was true of the Manics on their few confessional-ish songs but it was never James Dean Bradfield people went about slashing. (genuinely sometimes it seems like the collective fangirl unconsciousness just goes 'pick two most photogenic members: press play', though tbf this sort of thing always seems to be based on a lot of interview burble/'all rock n roll is homosexual' shirtsharing)

I'm sure there is a mentalist friendship between the two that's part of the context of their songs, but there's only one of them writing the lyrics here. One emo dude is putting both self-accusations and self-justifications into his best friend's mouth, so there's a funny frisson there, but there's nothing resembling the "here is a straight-up push-pull relationship between two best friends" of The Libertines' Can't Stand Me Now.

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

Idk idk idk idk cus they have explicitly said that Folie A Deux is the sound of them deconstructing their friendship. I think. Have I mentioned that I occasionally make huge sweeping assumptions apropos of absolutely nothing? *facedesk*

Tbh the entire comparison stems from having my iPhone on shuffle on the bus to work. *is in no way impulsive or irrational*

Bandslash is so philosophical. It is odd. And a bit awesome, obviously, because I am sucker for philosophy but it does seem so much more self-aware than other fanfic, possibly because as you say, it's sort of 'APROPOS OF NOTHING.' Oh idk, I am so not into fandom really so I'm probably just looking at it at the wrong angle or something.

[cis.livejournal.com]

to be fair i don't really read FOB interviews so-- idk.

I dunno I still thought the original point, this:
"The lyrical TMI gets the same heart-swelling-and-bursting formula right as, say, Pete Wentz or Conor Oberst does; a little too honest, a little too raw, a little too vicious and faintly embarassing for that."

is a really interesting one! I have for quite a while been wondering if there was anything in the idea of boy-emo and male r'n'b as corollaries, what they say about different forms of masculinity, different ways of showing masculine weakness, different relationships between emotionality and polish, etc. And ER are kind of 'male r'n'b done by girls'!

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

argh I have a reply to this but have accidentally called in IS services on myself so have to look like i'm working.

basically: i agree.

[ms-bracken.livejournal.com]

I CANNOT BELIEVE I MISSED THIS DISCUSSION, but quickly - I have always read Pete / fans lyrics as Pete / Patrick lyrics because of the dynamic where one writes and the other sings. So there's the same process of interpretation and misinterpretation, but the assumed closeness (of a fan to a boy in a band xe likes) is an actually closeness (two boys in a band).

Anyway will GET BACK TO WORK and / or listen to ER now...

[bengraham.livejournal.com]

Tbh I've pretty much accepted that discussion posts are met with general apathy. We have trained people to tick boxes too well.

Sometimes it's not just apathy. I read this post, found it very interesting, makes me want to check out the ER album, but aside from that, I have nothing particularly useful to add to the debate, so I'll keep quiet.

Just because it doesn't get hundreds of comments like a poll doesn't mean ppl aren't reading.

[piratemoggy.livejournal.com]

Well yes, I am just being grumpy because I'm bored and katstevens isn't around for me to annoy.

[edgeofwhatever.livejournal.com]

Same. Additionally, a lot of times stuff has already been discussed, on other people's journals and whatnot, before it finally surfaces here, so I'm sort of discussioned out. (In this case, Lex has already quoted everything they've ever done on every website ever, and I said my piece in my "So Good" blurb and comment over at the Jukebox (http://www.thesinglesjukebox.com/?p=390), and at this point I am unable to formulate additional thoughts about them.)

[edgeofwhatever.livejournal.com]

Uh, and I was going to conclude that comment by saying maybe we should all make more of an effort to post stuff we want to talk about here, rather than on our own journals/Tumblrs/Twitters/etc.