I said it ages ago, but nobody bit and I still want to talk about it, so I'll say it again:
I was always impressed with Lily as a lyricist (see "Knock 'Em Out"), but I was impressed with her ability to be clever and distinct -- I wasn't aware that she could be evocative. Her new stuff, though, hits harder than anything on Alright, Still ever did: "The Fear" starts off mocking, and turns sympathetic and chilling at the chorus, while "I Could Say" is honest and weary (and goes to a sort of "Say It Right" place). Which brings me to "Who'd of Known" -- there's such a distinct sense of place and time; it's almost as detailed as Autobiography. And she chooses just the right details: the way she orchestrates closeness, the intimacy of sitting around his house and watching his TV, how you can hear her satisfied smile on "you accidentally called me 'baby.'"
I don't think the brat is gone, though -- one of the new songs is built around a chorus that cheerfully goes, "Fuck you! / Fuck you very much."
Who'd Of Known, if it weren't coming out in 2009, would probably be one of my favourite songs of the year, for exactly the reasons you list. I enjoy Lily's sarcasm, but I have an (imagined?) sense that she's letting her guard down on a lot of these songs, and the returns are surprisingly rewarding.
A lot of our complaints about Kate Nash were that she writes detailed songs about nothing in particular. That said, I've always had a bit of a soft spot for Foundations, minus her vocal affectations, and Who'd Of Known almost sounds like the inverse of that song. Detailed and lived-in, but warm and loved and SURPRISED by it, rather than cynical, out of love and jaded.
no subject
Date: 2008-12-05 06:52 pm (UTC)I was always impressed with Lily as a lyricist (see "Knock 'Em Out"), but I was impressed with her ability to be clever and distinct -- I wasn't aware that she could be evocative. Her new stuff, though, hits harder than anything on Alright, Still ever did: "The Fear" starts off mocking, and turns sympathetic and chilling at the chorus, while "I Could Say" is honest and weary (and goes to a sort of "Say It Right" place). Which brings me to "Who'd of Known" -- there's such a distinct sense of place and time; it's almost as detailed as Autobiography. And she chooses just the right details: the way she orchestrates closeness, the intimacy of sitting around his house and watching his TV, how you can hear her satisfied smile on "you accidentally called me 'baby.'"
I don't think the brat is gone, though -- one of the new songs is built around a chorus that cheerfully goes, "Fuck you! / Fuck you very much."
no subject
Date: 2008-12-07 05:42 am (UTC)A lot of our complaints about Kate Nash were that she writes detailed songs about nothing in particular. That said, I've always had a bit of a soft spot for Foundations, minus her vocal affectations, and Who'd Of Known almost sounds like the inverse of that song. Detailed and lived-in, but warm and loved and SURPRISED by it, rather than cynical, out of love and jaded.