The dilettante/specialist thing is something I wrestle with so much! And I think the abundance of music at our fingertips is having an interesting effect on it, in that I think despite its potential to turn everyone in a dilettante as increasingly esoteric genres become accessible to them, it's making everyone a specialist as they find their niche and dig themselves into it. Philosophically I lean towards favouring dilettantism but you do need specialists out there - I'd love to be a specialist (indeed I think I'm getting more and more so when it comes to house and r&b) but I'd never be able to accept the price you pay for your knowledge, which is shutting yourself off completely from the rest of the musical world.
no subject
Date: 2007-03-12 01:27 pm (UTC)The dilettante/specialist thing is something I wrestle with so much! And I think the abundance of music at our fingertips is having an interesting effect on it, in that I think despite its potential to turn everyone in a dilettante as increasingly esoteric genres become accessible to them, it's making everyone a specialist as they find their niche and dig themselves into it. Philosophically I lean towards favouring dilettantism but you do need specialists out there - I'd love to be a specialist (indeed I think I'm getting more and more so when it comes to house and r&b) but I'd never be able to accept the price you pay for your knowledge, which is shutting yourself off completely from the rest of the musical world.