ext_380265 (![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
dubdobdee.livejournal.com) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
poptimists2006-05-25 01:42 pm
dubdobdee.livejournal.com) wrote in poptimists2006-05-25 01:42 pm
IMPORTANT CLARIFICATION
false metal = a subgenre of metal
fake rock = a subgenre of rock
bad pop = a subgenre of pop*
(also ps wow there is tons of grebt stuff on these threads!)
re the stones: the overlap year is 1966, when they were constantly in the charts, but "rock" had not yet firmed up as a "thing" (it was being done but not yet being pointed at unerringly) -- what's key to THEM tho is that they were already doing the "fake" thing as a self-marker -- they didn't play blues or R&B (old skool def) or country or soul, they played Fake Blues, Fake R&B, Fake Country, Fake Soul (not to be confused w.plastic soul!) (or indeed RUBBER SOUL!) -- later they purged their popness and became the "greatest rock'n'roll band in the world", and a certain amont of back formation and redefinition occurred
as actual overlap i would personally propose: under my thumb and mother's little helper
fake rock = a subgenre of rock
bad pop = a subgenre of pop*
(also ps wow there is tons of grebt stuff on these threads!)
re the stones: the overlap year is 1966, when they were constantly in the charts, but "rock" had not yet firmed up as a "thing" (it was being done but not yet being pointed at unerringly) -- what's key to THEM tho is that they were already doing the "fake" thing as a self-marker -- they didn't play blues or R&B (old skool def) or country or soul, they played Fake Blues, Fake R&B, Fake Country, Fake Soul (not to be confused w.plastic soul!) (or indeed RUBBER SOUL!) -- later they purged their popness and became the "greatest rock'n'roll band in the world", and a certain amont of back formation and redefinition occurred
as actual overlap i would personally propose: under my thumb and mother's little helper
haha that pesky fossil astrisk
no subject
no subject
(BTW i do not endorse this product or service except insofar as it is FUNNY)
no subject
paging mr hegel
yet there is no such thing as a contradiction!
Re: paging mr hegel
MOST ABSURD (hence korrekt) "ROCK AND POP AT ONCE" SUGGESTION PRIZE
no subject
shaniatwain shall meet --> hence the post-facto redefno subject