#2 in the Rock Sound Top 75 albums (http://www.rocksound.tv/blog/entry/top-75-albums-of-2008) (which is their pick, rather than the readers' poll where it ranked much lower)
#7 for Metal Hammer, which is probably about the highest they've ever ranked (http://www.metalhammer.co.uk/features/metal-hammer-critics’-top-50-albums-2008-9-7/)

*shrug* I'm not pretending to be incredibly accurate about the whole thing and I don't know that much about Pazz & Jop as a whole but I think they will get in there somewhere.